Cops blamed for ruckus

Brickfields folk claim police over-reacted in trying to control situation
Wednesday, October 28th, 2009 03:59:00

 

Brickfields
THE weekend ruckus in Brickfields, which had earlier been reportedly caused by unruly revellers, has now been blamed on police over-reaction.

 

S. Paran Jothy, a Gerakan Party branch chairman, told Malay Mail that he had tried to intervene in the fracas to calm down tempers.

“I wanted to defuse the situation but the police were not cooperative.”

Traders and residents had joined a multitude of people to usher in Deepavali at Jalan Tun Sambanthan
on Friday evening when the night turned into a few hours of daylight with non-stop rockets and fireworks lighting the sky.

But the celebrations were marred with the arrest of six people, including a minor, for what police say was due to the release of firecrackers along Jalan Tun Sambanthan.

Following the arrests, some 60 people surrounded a police patrol car parked near the former Peking Hotel and demanded their release.

Paran, one of the residents who was in the thick of action, claimed he had tried to speak to the police to mediate between them and the crowd.

“Instead, I was told by a senior police officer that they would not back down. They were adamant in arresting them.”

He claimed the police caught the six while they were lighting the firecrackers and alleged that one of the plainclothed policeman even kicked a suspect.

Paran, who is also Hindu Serva Sangam coordinator, said it was not right for the police to wait and then act on the people who were letting off firecrackers to celebrate the Hindu festival.

“Why did they not go after those who were selling firecrackers in a big way? Why were only the small fry caught during police operations?”

Brij Jayaram Kathivavelu, a legal assistant and a Brickfields resident also present during the police action,
wondered why police had acted that night.

“Every time we have some kind of celebration, we seem to have problems with the police.”

He said that on the eve of the Tamil new year on April 13, the police tried to drown out with wailing
sirens the sound of drums and trumpets welcoming Lembah Pantai MP Nurul Izzah Anwar.

He claimed three police patrol cars were packed at the pet shop opposite Joy supermarket, with their sirens on full blast, as Nurul and her entourage, heading the opposite direction, were being welcomed to the sounds of Indian drums and trumpets.

However, hair salon operator S. Shan admitted that this year’s celebrations might have gone overboard
with outsiders joining in.

“It is sort of an annual event. Every year, we have people letting of fireworks and firecrackers on the eve of Deepavali. But, this year, it was near madness.

“Some of the cars were trapped because merrymakers got on to the road along this whole stretch to let off firecrackers.”

Due to the overwhelming crowd that night, he said that he was only able to close his shop around 3am because of fantastic demand for his services.

Another video retailer, S. Peraisamy, who stood as an independent candidate in the 2008 elections in Lembah Pantai, said the police action that night gave a bad impression of the force.

“In the first place, why are traders allowed to sell firecrackers? They should go after everybody in possession of firecrackers.”

He said the act of giving 10 permits to sell firecrackers to traders who set up temporary stalls during the festivities made it hard to make them accountable as they were there only temporarily.

“They are the ones who sold the heavy-duty firecrackers,” he added.

Comments

I fully support the police action...

Submitted by Anonymous on Wednesday, November 4th, 2009.
Breaking the law is breaking the law O.K. No need to say things like why don't the police go after those selling fireworks etc. Its like saying if someone uses a knife to kiil, we should blame the shop who sold him the knife ?? What logic is that ??. As such don't blame the police for trying to maintain the peace for others (because other people around the same area have rights too you know).

Submitted by calvin on Tuesday, November 3rd, 2009.
Once you have no trust in your national police force, why don't you have your own private security patrol like the one we have now in many residential gated communities. It can be a possible solution to have bangladeshi, tibetans, indians, indonesians, patrolling the whole Brickfields area giving the security you need most. You can also control them and can ask what you want and don't want them to do in your neighbourhoods , and the best thing is they are under your control. Private security businesses are mushrooming nowadays giving additional jobs & money to people and security to community of course. Is it because of police forces couldn't do their job? or not enough manpower in the police force? where criminal rates are keep multiplying. Do the Brickfields community want to have this kind of private patrol? Will you put trust to this kind of people guarding your area??

Submitted by Anonymous on Sunday, November 1st, 2009.
There is a perception among some Indians that the police are racist towards Indians. This is the root of the social ill. Malaysian government in general and PDRM specifically should be careful so that such perception is not fortified further. Having said that, there is no room for hooliganism if any.

Submitted by Road Warrior on Sunday, November 1st, 2009.
Well done PDRM! Dare to light the crackers, then be bold to face the consequences!

Submitted by sillylupie on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
Its time Government come out with a new law - Canning hooligans and barbarians not jailing them.

Submitted by Brickfields Indian on Saturday, October 31st, 2009.
As an Indian over age 50,I tend to agree with Brickfields indian.He just sums up the problem of rowdy 'Indian youth ' who may be a small segment but actually do a lot of harm to the image of Indians.Once they are in their numbers they are very unruly ,menacing,vulgar and fuelled by alcohol and designer drugs are a real danger to anyone who stands up to them.Murder and and calculated maiming and bestial torture of their 'enemies' is not above them.Many are just teens or in their early twenties .Who raised them?Who bails them out when they get into trouble,its the parents.Who corrects them?I'm not defending the police as one always get the impression that the police are not so concerned about the mat rempits menace.What ever the rowdy elements cannot be allowed to be a danger to the peaceful revellers and passers by .

Submitted by Indian observer on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
Grow up and wake up fellow Malaysians ................ there are rule of law!

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
I am a Malaysian and have seen this is not the ordinary Indians but the gangster element among them.They should have a garland of firecrackers put around their neck and see , how fast they will want the police.Firecrackers are NOT to be thrown at anybody.Anyone throwing Firecrackers at anyone, is acting of to maim the individual.People throwing firecrackers should be arrested at once, irrespective of whether they are tamils, or anyone else.Just because it was divali is no excuse for such unruly , uncivilised and jungle behaviour in public places.The police, when they do their job, they should be congragulated.In this instance they should be congragulated for a job done well.

Submitted by EthnicMalaysian on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
It's said, when the police act, the politicians get involved, the police was wrong. When the police don't act, the politicians get involved, the police are again wrong. I think I've had enough of politicians who gets in the way. Just let the police do their work. Those of you who condone the thugs' behaviour, you are no different from the thugs themselves.

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
There must be a reason as to why the police were there to arrest people letting off firecrackers. I am an expat living here for the last 5 years and have been to Brickfields 3 times, bringing my family and friends from Sweden and compared to the Chinese New Year and the muslim hari raya, the celebration in Brickfields are far more aggressive and chaotic. Perhaps local indian community leaders should help tje police to prevent rather than preventing the police from discharging and it is a silly shame that political movements get involved in these types of incidents. When will you people grow up? The public obviously called up the police to act as the police station is very close and they would have long imposed their authority but I believe that the police decided to allow things to happen until they go overboard. It is a shame that because of a few, the majority acts using their hearts instead of their head and we have , in the past, been thwon firecrackers as we drove last year and we noticed that people just did not do anything to stop firecrackers thrown at passing cars. My husband almost wanted to stop and confront the throwers but we also realised that indians are generally mopre aggressive than the other races here. Wake up and grow up please.

Submitted by Marie on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
I have been to Sweden , Belgium and France recently and on an outing on Friday night I see broken bottles everywhere after people had drank their beer. Does that mean all Europeans are barbarians?

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
You can also see broken beer bottles in Bukit Bintang area and sometimes in Bangsar as well as anywhere in the world. One needs not have a PhD to know this! The point is very simple - community or political people must not try and be a hero when the law is broken clearly. Dont look for excuses - find solutions - only then your country can really achieve the 1 Malaysia concept. Your police are doing just fine - just do not punish the whole force because of a few bad apples. After all, your police force are not made up of supermen or superwomen - theyre just humans like us. Help the police and you will help everyone. Condemn the police for their good work and your community will get the blame and negative image. It is silly to cpmpare Brickfields with Sweden, Belgium, France or anywhere as the discussion is al about what has happened and may well happen again in the location where the report is. Try and imagine when you have 2 and 5 year olds in your car travelling slowly when firecrackers are exploding just outside the car doors?

Submitted by Marie on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
No. they are merely descendants of barbarians but are major litter bugs.

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
If you were caught in Brickfields at that time with the hooligan throwing the firecrakers at you, I am very sure that you'll call them much worse than 'barbarians'. I strongly suggest you to go Brickfields at the same time next year to fully understand the situation.

Submitted by Ksaw on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
There will be no supply if there is no demand . . blame yourselves for buying it in the first place ! and stop blaming other people, and making them your punching bag for not having things your way. hope the next time you guys decide to light up a fire cracker, it will also light up some other part of your body as well against your will. then blame the people who made the fire crackers eh?

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
Catch the low grade criminals and stay away when your dear life is in danger. Malaysian Police is the best.

Submitted by Ravi on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
As if you can do better . .

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
Ya right.Blame it on the police. There's no pleasing some people. The police were there to keep the peace. If the police didn't do anything what's the point of having a police force? Aren't "revellers" supposed to follow the rules? In this case they are playing with fire crackers and disturbing public the which is against the law.Licenses are given to vendors to sell sparklers not firecrackers. S. Paran Jothy, a Gerakan Party branch chairman should've have told the revellers to stop playing fire crackers instead of waiting for things to escalate until the police come..The police are called by the public who are caught in the chaotic situation caused by the so called "revellers" who went too far by throwing firecrackers at passing vehicles.. So what do YOU do if it happens to you?

Submitted by Happy Dewali on Wednesday, October 28th, 2009.
I think it's not fair that only during a certain festive occasion do the police COME OUT and PLAN to arrest people who play with firecrackers. I am sure that every year during two more main festival occasions there are also people who play with firecrackers but do not get arrested. All you hear from newspapers during the other two festive seasons are "this child got injured playing firecrackers" and "that man got burnt playing firecrackers" but no news about arrests conducted by our police force. This is blatant racism! I hope that one day, all these officers who practice racism will reap what they sow. It may not be now, but sooner of later, karma or God will catch up with them. By that time, all we can say is GOOD LUCK AND GODSPEED! But I do have to agree with Happy Dewali. If the situation gets bad, then the police should do their job to maintain peace and protect innocent citizens.

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
Please do not conclude things. We know Fire crackers are banned but yet we play with them. So far have we heard about Police have arrested people playing fire crackers on Deepavali day other than in Brickfields? I am a Brickfields resident and believe me there was total choas on Deepavali eve caused by hooligans who came from outside. They boozed openly, throw leud remarks on girls who were with family members and running ruckus. If i was in power , i will round up all these rowdies and make them to spend their Deepavali in the jail. I just understand why whenever there is a large indian gattering , our youths love to cause trouble compare to other races . Brickfields Indian

Submitted by Brickfields Indian on Friday, October 30th, 2009.
just because you dont hear it, doesn't mean it did not happen. if it was not for these 'mobsters' surrounding the patrol car, and PKR taking the opportunity to play 'hero' and going to the press with this, it would not have made it in the papers rite?

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, October 29th, 2009.
Syndicate content

Disclaimer | Contact Us | Back to Top Δ

Contact our advertising team to place an advertisement in Malay Mail, Malay Mail Online, and Mail on Sunday.

Copyright 2009 Malay Mail Sdn. Bhd.