Court rules in favour of Kelantan prince

Friday, November 6th, 2009 05:09:00

TEENAGE princess Manohara Odelia Pinot is crushed. Her claims of being sexually and physically ravaged by her Kelantan prince husband have turned out to be a stardust-sprinkled illusion.

The twitchily restless 17-year old received more bad news yesterday when the High Court ruled that she and her fugitive mother Daisy Fajarina would have to pay Tengku Temenggong Kelantan Tengku Muhammad Fakhry for defaming him.

They failed to prove their allegations against Tengku Fakhry, 31, by not attending court and engaging new lawyers in his RM105 million defamation suit.

The court allowed Tengku Fakhry to enter judgment in default against mother and daughter. It will ascertain damages later.

On Oct 29, the court gave Manohara and her mother until yesterday to appoint new lawyers or risk having a judgment in default entered against them. Then, Messrs Fakrul Hisham Abdullah and Associates withdrew as their solicitors on record.

Tengku Fakhry’s lawyer Mohd Haaziq Pillay said: “They had their chance. Now, my client feels vindicated. The defendants have been given the opportunity to appear in court with evidence to support their allegations. But until today, they have not turned up. Money is not the issue for my client. This is about his dignity and reputation.”

The past few days have been torrid for Manohara, a well-known socialite in Indonesia, whose relationship with her mother, sources say, got strained recently.

Then, menacing Daisy got hospitalised this week, not because of the consequences of edgy relationship with her daughter, but apparently to avoid the police.

Jakarta police are looking for her in connection with a report by the owner of Stock House Butik, Sooni Ismono, alleging more than RM250,000 embezzlement by Daisy. The owner claimed that the deal involved high fashion leather handbags that Daisy was to source from Europe while she was in France in 2003.

Things got worse two days ago when Syariah lawyers — Mohd Faiz Adnan and Roshdan Sujak Rafie — pulled out from representing Manohara and Daisy in two cases in the Syariah High and Lower Courts in Kota Baru.

It will get worse on Sunday when the court hears Tengku Fakhry’s demands that the pair return a loan of about RM1 million and that Manohara stays loyal to him.

Manohara has taken a huge risk. By not returning to her husband and executing her duties as a wife, as stipulated by Islamic law and as a princess, she stands to lose her title of Cik Puan Temenggong and all material rights.

No reason was stated but it was learnt that these lawyers, too, did not get the cooperation of mother and daughter, similar to another legal firm that withdrew from representing them in the RM105 million defamation suit.

Their lawyers were frustrated that the information they received from Manohara and her mother was “just hearsay”.

Even, the medical report stating that Manohara had suffered severe beatings at the hands of Tengku Fakhry was not produced.

The out-of-control malevolence of Daisy, who many blame for leading Manohara astray, had stoked anger among Indonesians who cried for justice.

Daisy has been sentenced to 18 months’ jail in absentia in France for submitting her adopted daughter Shaliha to undignified working conditions and assault, dating back to 1998 and remains a fugitive.

Manohara’s biological father American George Manz had described Daisy as an “evil mother” and asked her to free the former teen model from her “wickedness”.

Over the past few months, public opinion has dramatically shifted in this high-society scandal with Manohara and Daisy unable to prove their allegations against Tengku Fakhry.

Comments posted on the Malay Mail online indicate that many, making neat connections between an “evil mother” and the plight of a princess, want to see a happy ending to this saga with the prince and princess reuniting.

For those of a sunny disposition, the scandal did provide some entertaining interludes, particularly claims by businessman Datuk Kadar Shah that he was the “negotiator” in the marital dispute.

Kadar Shah had also stated that he had helped Manohara to flee from her “abusive” husband from Singapore on May 31 when the couple was in the republic to visit the Sultan of Kelantan at the Mount Elizabeth Hospital.

Comments

perhaps the girl should sue the prince in the indonesian courts for double the amount. i am sure she would get such a judgment as easily as our prince got his through our impeccable courts. what a circus.

Submitted by Anonymous on Wednesday, November 11th, 2009.
Good suggestion. Out of 159 countries, Malaysia is number 39 where as Indonesia is 138 in the list corruption by Country. I am sure Manohara can pay for a judgement that will be to her advantage.

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, November 12th, 2009.
the conduct of a royalty has been put into question here. even if the cases are not contested there will always remain the question of whether the royalty exercised influence over the courts. for the sake of justice, surely there is some lawyer out there who can assist manohara. dont leave her alone please.

Submitted by violet tang on Tuesday, November 10th, 2009.
Damn if you do, damn if you don't. If TT wins, the opinion is that the decision is influanced by the royalty. If he lose, he is the villain.

Submitted by Anonymous on Wednesday, November 11th, 2009.
i would like to make a proposal of starting a fund for manohara. if those who are interested in the truth can conribute a small amount to her, then we can help her pay the legal fees. i can only conslude that money is keeping her back from fighting him in court. i think she would not be talking cheap without any basis. i dont know how to get this fund going. can anyone give some ideas?

Submitted by sokong Manohara on Sunday, November 8th, 2009.
Daisy Fajarina has a history of lying and has been convicted in France. Even though it was the mother who committed the crime in France, I will not want to waste my money on helping Manohara as I feel the mother is the architect of the drama. Manohara is the puppet. If they belief they are right, at least give the evidence to their lawyers in Malaysia. None of that happened. Just remember, their lawyers in Malaysia resigned due to lack of information.

Submitted by Anonymous on Monday, November 9th, 2009.
How lucky is that Mano to get married, and live prestigiously in our country MALAYSIA and could get all those luxuries of our country compared to their poor people in Indonesia. She came here and was given a high rank or status. As a CIK PUAN TEMENGGUNG, she was protected by the royal rules and living and talking with a very high class people (WITH THE SULTAN!) even Malaysian people ourself have no chances to get and experience all that. it is she who is NOT THANKFUL! of course because of her mother's she turned out like that BUT she was blind from the truth because of her LOVE TOWARDS HER MOTHER...and i think Tenku Fakhry realized this and that's why he still yet not divorce her wife since he knows that she is not guilty but her mother. so IT IS CLEAR that our prince has a good moral and a very responsible man! absolutlely she is very young and still wants to have a normal life without formal rules.maybe it is quite hard for her to adapt to the royal rules at that very young age. but all this kept her safe from a wild gossip, even the proof of violence is not very clear.pictures can be edited!

Submitted by PROUD TO BE MALAYSIAN on Sunday, November 8th, 2009.
Whatever the reasons and outcome of this case, I find strange that a good name of a person can be equated with money, i.e. RM 100 million ++. Strange, in this world people tend to think money is a good way to compensate or punish a person. It is shameful to equate a person's dignity with money. I wonder is such a amount justifiable? Only God know.

Submitted by Road Warrior on Sunday, November 8th, 2009.
You writing was a nice read...but appears a little biased, if I may say. Poor Girl.....Really...that's how and what comes to mind, s Put yourself in her shoes........Is there a reason why she doesn't want to be with him.....he is a prince... and she is wife and enjoys all kinds of luxuries etc.. I can only imagine all the luxuries.... but she doesn't want it and she wants to get from this prince guy.... and the whole world doesn't want her to go.... Doesn't she have a choice...say ...mind you she only gets to live once... she deserves to live the life she chooses...wouldn't you say....is that not right... She ran away...Why?.... Like you said she is the wife of a prince..... but she didn't want it.....anymore...now...don't you think there is valid reason to dig up and find out...why someone could throw away the chance of lifetime and run away... To be honest, we the readers don't get one little bit about the prince's lifestyle....maybe you should write on him too.... I am sure a lot of people want to know..... Legally, is any contract binding on a 17 year old......I don't know...but sure would like to know.... I dare you to write about the young prince......why???? because there is the issue...the girl ran away and she is low keyed and not running all over the place partying with other guys and such.....like so many have done.... Regards, MICHAEL JAMES Being a wife of a prince...a royalty.... It is the girl's life.....she lived with him for a while... and she doen't want to be with the guy....

Submitted by michael james on Saturday, November 7th, 2009.
I have been waiting for the answer to that question - why did she ran away when she is surrounded by the privileges of being in the royal family. She had her chance through the court to explain her side of the story. Did she use the opportunity to defend her self? No!!! Now the next question is - why didn't Manohara defend herself in court?

Submitted by Anonymous on Sunday, November 8th, 2009.
this is how the media is responding in indonesia: Kapanlagi.com - Secara mengejutkan, mantan model Manohara Odelia Pinot harus menerima kekalahan atas tuntutan mantan suaminya Teuku Fakhry di Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur. Perempuan yang mengaku menjadi korban Kekerasan Dalam Rumah Tangga (KDRT) itu pun diwajibkan membayar ganti rugi sebesar RM105 juta atau sekitar Rp291 miliar. Vonis majelis hakim yang dipimpin Shazali Hidayat Shariff menjatuhkan vonis pada Kamis (5/11). Majelis hakim menilai Manohara dan ibunya, Daisy Fajarina, terbukti melakukan fitnah. Lalu, bagaimana tanggapan ibunda Manohara, Daisy Fajarina? Saat ditemui di kediamannya, perempuan berdarah Bugis itu mengaku telah mengetahui mengenai kabar tersebut melalui sambungan telepon. Meski belum mendapatkan kejelasan secara sempurna. "Saya belum tahu secara jelas keputusannya seperti apa. Makanya, saya akan konsultasi dulu dengan pengacara saya biarkan mereka yang akan berbicara," ungkap Daisy yang ditemui di kediamannya di Kawasan Slipi, Jakarta Barat, Kamis (5/11) malam. Daisy pun menegaskan, apa yang diputuskan oleh Pengadilan di Malaysia belumlah menjadi keputusan yang mutlak. Pihaknya pun bersiap untuk melakukan banding karena merasa diperlakukan secara tidak adil. "Itukan bukan keputusan mutlak, kita masih bisa banding, itu masih panjang prosesnya. Kalau tante sendiri belum dengar secara pasti, jadi seperti yang tante katakan, kalau urusan hukum kita serahkan kepada pengacara," ujar Daisy. Seperti diberitakan sebelumnya, Tengku Fakhry menggugat Manohara dan Daisy Fajarina karena dinilai telah menyebarkan fitnah. Fakhry tersinggung dituding telah melakukan KDRT dan kekerasan seksual. (kpl/adt/dar) Banyak Persoalan, Ibunda Manohara Dirawat di RS Kapanlagi.com - Ibunda Manohara Odelia Pinot, Daisy Fajarina harus menjalani perawatan di Rumah Sakit Siloam, Graha Medika, Kebon Jeruk, Jakarta Barat, akibat stress dan serangan maag. Kini perempuan berdarah Bugis itu dirawat di kamar 3102, didampingi putri kesayangannya yang pernah menjadi korban kekerasan Pangeran Kelantan, Malaysia. Daisy tidak membantah jika sakit yang dideritanya kali ini, lantaran banyaknya persoalan yang harus dihadapi. Dirinya sering lupa makan, hingga berdampak buruk pada penyakit maag yang sudah sekian lama diderita. "Habis gimana ya, kalau nggak dipikirkan, kan ini masalah anak sendiri. Tapi begitu kembali ke saya, justru banyak fitnah, banyak serangan balik, ya Tante sebagai manusia biasa hanya bisa ikhlas dan berdoa kepada yang Maha Segalanya," ungkapnya. Ditemui di kamar tempatnya dirawat, Senin (2/10), Daisy mengaku sudah dua hari mendapatkan perawatan. Awalnya hanya demam, disusul dengan sakit kepala hebat. "Setelah diperiksa, setelah didiagnosis ternyata sakit maag tante kambuh, dan dokter bilang kecapekan. Ini semua Mano yang sibuk. Mano yang bawa tante ke rumah sakit, Mano yang maksa tante untuk ke sini dan semuanya Mano yang urus," terangnya. Pihaknya juga belum dapat memastikan, apakah hanya sakit maag atau ada penyakit yang lain. Sehingga dokter berencana melakukan rontgen di sekitar kepala, untuk mengetahui lebih jelas penyebabnya. "Nggak tahu juga ya, soalnya mendadak banget hanya pusing aja, rencananya mau di MRA (rontgen kepala, red), kalau masalah makan sih sebenarnya tante lumayan disiplin, tapi memang, sudah nggak kuat aja," terangnya. Dokter hanya menyarankan untuk banyak istirahat, dan tidak boleh makan pedas dan masam. Hingga kini pun belum tahu kapan dirinya diizinkan pulang. "Belum tahu sampai kapan, tapi kalau dibanding kemarin sudah mendingan, perut udah nggak sakit tinggal pusingnya aja," pungkasnya.

Submitted by Andy Malelo on Saturday, November 7th, 2009.
she doesnt need the title of cik puan temenggong kelantan because.............. Mano Gets Own Royal Title in Solo Former teenage model-cum-instant celebrity, Manohara Odelia Pinot, who shot to fame following her short-lived marriage to a Malaysian prince, now has a royal title of her very own. Sunan Pakubuwono XIII Hangabehi, the head of the royal line in Solo, Central Java, bestowed the 17-year-old with the royal title of Kanjeng Mas Ayu as part of the pomp to mark his fifth anniversary on the throne. The royal spokeswoman, Princess Gusti Raden Ayu Koes Murtiyah, said the award was an intellectual rebuke to the royal family of Kelantan, to which Manohara’s husband belongs. “She was given the royal title because, first, she is still the legitimate wife of a prince,” she said. “And secondly, to remind the family of Tengku Fakhry that the domestic issues of a royal family should not be revealed so openly to the public.”

Submitted by Andy Malelo on Saturday, November 7th, 2009.
mano wrote in her blog soon after her marriage to TT: Recently i got married. Lucky for me i am married with a royal family from malaysia. currently my marriage is very happy, instead of many internet gossip about my unhappy life. Attending functions with my loved ones is my dream. living a formal and informal life like a princess is everyone's dream and now i'm living on everyones' dream.

Submitted by seriling on Saturday, November 7th, 2009.
baik mano cepat cepat mintak ampun sebelum masuk 'jail'... hehehe, Ku TT kasik ajar Si Manoharta dan mak dia yg gila harta ni cukup2... LS, jgn lupa update perkembangan sidang perbicaraan hari ni eh... sure thing Mano tak berani pijak kaki kat bumi Kelantan, kang tak pasal2 muntah darah terkena 'tulah' ..hehehe..

Submitted by cengkerik007 on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
said... Kenapa media di Indonesia tak keluarkan berita Manohara dan Daisy Fajarina lagi? Kalau dulu tiap tiap hari ada je cerita Minah dua orang ni. Kalau ikut standard dulu, kes Daisy Fajarina masok hospital mesti dilapurkan. Sekarang ni langsung senyap. Ni hal keluar masuk mahkamah dan peguam tarik diri pun tak ada dalam media Indonesia. Apa, cerita Manohara dan Daisy Fajarina ni dah tak menarik lagi so media dah tak boleh dapat untung macam dulu dulu lagi? Kalau macam tu, media di Indonesia cuma interested dengan how much money they can make but not necessarily the 'news' worthiness? Atau pun Manohara dan Daisy Fajarina dah tak relevant lagi? I don't think so.

Submitted by Tembam on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
Dasiy Fajarina dikejarkan ke rumah sakit akibat 'kepala pusing' lagi. Dia dimasukkan ke wad dirumah sakit Siloam, Graha Medika, Kebun Jeruk, Jakarta barat sudah 4 hari dan menetap dikamar 3102. Manohara disampingnya seorang diri kerana Dewi hilang entah dimana. Pinot pula sedang sakit dirumah dan malu untuk keluar rumah kerana walaupun tinggal bersama Dasiy Fajarina tapi kamar lain-lain, kabarnya kamar Dasiy Fajarina ditumpang oleh orang lain yang menjadi 'body guard' sepanjang malam. Sejak akhir-akhir ini, rumahtangga Dasiy Fajarina tidak terurus seperti ketika Manohara baru pulang ke Indonesia, lagi pun Dasiy Fajarina sudah tidak diberi kebenaran oleh Manohara untuk terus membelanjakan wang hasil dari senetron Manohara lagi. itulah menyebabkan Dasiy Fajarina 'Pusing Kepala' kerana banyak lagi hutang yang belum dijelaskan. Terakhir ini, Ritz Carlton Hotel sedang mengejar Dasiy Fajarina kerana sewaan semasa tinggal di Appartment Ritz Carlton tidak dibayar. Banyak jutaan yang masih belum dituntas dan ini agak memalukan Manohara yang menyebabkan Manohara sudah terasa dingin dengan Dasiy Fajarina, manakala Dewi Seri Asih sedang menghadapi masaalah bayaran wang kuliah yang belum beres. Berapa pula jumlah wang kena bayar yang akan dijatuhkan oleh Mahkamah Sivil Kuala Lumpur terhadap Dasiy Fajarina dan Manohara kerana menfitnah TT. Dasiy Fajarina akan lagi 'pusing kepala' apabila tidak mampu membayar tuntutan yang disaman oleh TT. Bilakah agaknya Dasiy Fajarina akan keluar dari rumah sakit atau Dasiy Fajarina akan terus sakit atau buat-buat sakit sehingga satu hari nanti dia akan dipindahkan ke PENJARA. Terimalah padahnya!.

Submitted by anakKelantan on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
With love, you should go ahead and take the risk of getting hurt because love is an amazing feeling. Look at the amounts Fakhry lavished on Mano and that to me is love. i rather TT hurts now and finds someone worthy of his care and affection.

Submitted by Vasanthan on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
You know the old saying; marry in haste and repent at leisure. It’s easy to scoff at celebs who rush in and out of love but let’s face it; most of us aren’t surrounded by beautiful people all day. We interact with our dry cleaner and the pizza delivery guy/gal. Temptation is not all around us and if we were to make a big mistake, we don’t have a team of hotshot lawyers to get us out of it.

Submitted by yohdonyo on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
The probability of a celebrity marriage surviving is only 35 percent. Now aren't you glad nobody's ever heard of you?

Submitted by justice bao on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
u got that one right!!!....LOL

Submitted by Anonymous on Monday, November 16th, 2009.
Manohara must remember that she is still the wife of a prince (legitimate wife) and must behave like one. she owes us, the people, an explanation and should be doing so in court. im still not convinced about the whole thing and pray that mano would turn up in court this sunday and contest the demands TT is making.

Submitted by samantha on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
It's no hyperbole to say that, over the past months, TT's very reputation has been hanging perilously in the balance. He has been vindicated and he doesnt need mano or her wicked mother back in his life. stop trying to get them back together because it is nauseating just thinking about it. malaysia doesnt need a sly princess and her evil mum.

Submitted by Dr Ramesh on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
For the marriage counseling buffs out there, here is the authors’ list of popular hypotheses that have been proposed, and stated as if they were truth, without much empirical backing: Conflict avoidance and bickering about trivial issues are dysfunctional. (Raush et al., 1974) A dominance structure is dysfunctional. (Gottman, 1979) The lack of a dominance structure is dysfunctional. (Kolb and Straus, 1974) A "demand-withdraw" pattern or a "pursuer-distancer" pattern is dysfunctional. (Heavey, Christensen, and Malamuth, 1995) Not being able to change one another’s behavior is dysfunctional. (Jacobson and Margolin, 1979) A good marriage is characterized by acceptance in which spouses accept one another as they are and do not try to get behavior change. (Jacobson and Christensen, 1998) Poor problem solving is dysfunctional. (Jacobson, 1989) Mind-reading," or attributing motives or behaviors to one’s spouse is dysfunctional. (Watzlawick, Beavin, and Jackson, 1967) Not meta-communicating is dysfunctional. (Bateson et al., 1956) Need complimentarity is functional. (Winch, 1958) Healthy marriage is not possible unless neuroses in one’s primary family are resolved. (Scharff and Scharff, 1991) Most marital conflict is projection (Meissner, 1978), but first the marriage needs to become "conscious." (Hendrix, 1988) Marriages start off happy, but over time "reinforcement erosion" occurs and that is the source of marital dysfunction. (Jacobson and Margolin, 1979) Only equalitarian marriage is functional. (Schwartz, 1994)

Submitted by Dr Ramesh on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
unresolved family issues tend to get hotter than a pan of jewel yams, because they keep us from being as close as we want to be to our families. Well, we may want to be estranged from our particular family -- but we want to be a member of some family where we feel loved, respected and appreciated.

Submitted by Dr Ramesh on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
daisy will soon pay for her sins and mano also should be taught a lesson. but in the end, i agree that the young couple should get together and forget the past. it isnt going to easy for both of them but give it a try, TT. forgiveness will ultimately change the whole perspective of your life and image. and i know that someone like you can get any woman you want but you didnt throughout the whole episode and that speaks highly of you.

Submitted by andre on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
Start re-building your life, TT. forget mano. As arduous as it could feel, it's really necessary to commence considering moving on. There is always the possibility that you can not get back together, so start socializing, meeting people and doing the stuff that you like. Refrain from feeling pitying yourself or hiding out on your own in a room. You will end up depressed and sad. Instead, find out something that you love doing and run doing it to help you focus. Best wishes, TT.

Submitted by Dr Zainal Sulaiman on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
So all these were lies? 1. daily routine of rape, abuse, torture and drug injections which made her vomit blood. 2. Sexual abuse and sexual harassment every time manohara did not want to have sexual intercourse 3.Some parts of her body were cut by a razor. Are they insane or what?

Submitted by zarina on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
TT. Stay positive and say positive stuff about your mano from now on. This can be hard for you but it's one of the easiest approaches to obtain her concentration. The friends will tell your mano the positive things you say about her and that will as time goes on start to warm her heart to you.

Submitted by coleen on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
Relationship breakups can be very heartbreaking . You might feel that you have lost totally and you cannot move on without your wife or husband. In the end, most people triumph over these feelings and move on with their lives. It takes long for some people to go on. If you actually love your ex partner and you still desire them back, you'll be pleased to discover that you still have hope. A lot of relationships can be saved.

Submitted by cheryl tan on Friday, November 6th, 2009.
Syndicate content

Disclaimer | Contact Us | Back to Top Δ

Contact our advertising team to place an advertisement in Malay Mail, Malay Mail Online, and Mail on Sunday.

Copyright 2009 Malay Mail Sdn. Bhd.