Shock over whipping sentence

Ministry upset over unprecedented move by Syariah Court
Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009 06:26:00
Syariah
WOMEN leaders from two opposing political camps have come out strongly against the whipping sentence meted out on a 32-year old model for drinking beer by a Syariah court in Kuantan early this week.

 

Women, Family and Community Development Minister Senator Datuk Seri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil expressed shock over the unprecedented sentence.

"I am extremely shocked and feel very strongly about this new development. Though it is wrong in Syariah to consume alcohol, the punishment must be fair and just," she said, adding her ministry is following the case ery closely.

"What is wrong is wrong but the implementation of the Syariah must be fair and just to everyone, including women," she said, adding in civil law there is no provision for women to be caned.

As much as she wants to express her feelings, Sharizat said, being a former officer of the court she has to restrain herself as the case has gone up for appeal.

Echoing a similar opinion, the Member of Parliament for Titiwangsa, Dr Lo'Lo Datuk Mohd Ghazali, noted that she was surprised that caning or whipping of women was sanctioned under the Syariah law in Malaysia.

"The punishment must be more educational rather than causing hurt to a woman to make her reform," she said, adding the whipping sentence was very harsh.

It's the first time she is hearing about a whipping punishment. "So far nobody, not even a male, has been whipped under the Syariah in Malaysia," said the Pas Women wing head, who last month came to the defence of Sisters in Islam after PAS announced that it wanted the National Fatwa Council to ban the non-governmental organisation.

"I do not know how the whipping punishment is going to be carried out on women. Is it going to be symbolic or real whipping," she said.

Whipping is a norm in many Islamic States. Last month in Bangladesh a widow was whipped 202 times and a man 101 times following a fatwa by a religious leader for their alleged involvement in "anti-social activity" in a village in south eastern Bangladesh, prompting local protests and action by the police.

Piara Begum, a widow of 40, and Mamun Miah, 25, were whipped before hundreds of people at Khaiyar in Comilla district. The woman fell unconscious and was rushed to hospital and was admitted for intensive treatment.

On Monday in Kuantan, Syariah judge Datuk Abdul Rahman Yunus fined the model RM5,000 and imposed six whippings after she pleaded guilty to consuming an alcoholic drink in public last year. In making his ruling, judge Abdul Rahman said that if Kartika Sari Dewi Shukarnor, from Sungai Siput, Perak failed to pay the fine of
RM5,000, she would be imprisoned for three years.

Kartika was accused of consuming a beer at Cherating Bay Lounge, the Legend Hotel in Cherating at about
11.40pm on July 11 last year.

She was charged under Section 136 of the Pahang Administration of the Islam Law and Malay Custom Enactment. The accused, who cried when the judgement was delivered,  said she would file an appeal
through her counsel, Mohd Zuki Che Mat Ghani. Syariah deputy public prosecutor Saiful Idham Sahimi appeared for the prosecution.

Comments

a learnt to be lesson for kartika, to be born as a muslimah she should know-gist of a sin is a beer@alchohol. Congratulation to the judge and Syariah Court you do the right things.

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, July 31st, 2009.
luckily kartika is not your loves.. one. wat happen if this thing happen to be one of your loves one., family member, relatives or your close friends..

Submitted by Anonymous on Wednesday, August 12th, 2009.
Malaysia boleh!!! I think stating that Malaysia is a moderate islamic country is stretching it a bit. Islamic conservatism here hopes to reach the saudi arabian level of interpretation. Personal freedom to decide what you want to do doesn't apply anymore. And I definitely agree the shariah court has gone way out of control.

Submitted by Anonymous on Sunday, July 26th, 2009.
Why are we deteriotating into the dark ages. I thought we were a modern Malaysia. Maybe we are allowing a new breed of Talibanism to creep in. Take a look at Jalan Bukit Bintang - I cannot believe I am in Kuala Lumpur. Help we are losing our identity our own uniqueness of being a multicultural nation!

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, July 23rd, 2009.
This is sending a wrong message. It is ok for corruption. It is not ok to drink beer.

Submitted by D Eva on Thursday, July 23rd, 2009.
Even though I find it outrageous but I think this should be a good start for the Muslim people not only in Malaysia but all over the world to wake up and realize our duty as a Muslim. Today Muslim people man and women are more daring drinking openly in public. We have to start somewhere to stop this. Congratulation to The Syariah Court. We must remember that drinking can lead to other bad thing such as killing others by drunk driving. What if that person who was killed was your love one......... It is also an insult to me as Muslim.

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, July 23rd, 2009.
How are they going to carry the whipping? I dont think malaysia has any whipping punishment based on the true syariah law. The current whipping is based on the conventional law -- which I think is far from syariah 'whipping'..

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, July 23rd, 2009.
Malaysia has a reputation as a moderate Muslim country. If it is carried out, this barbaric punishment will not only hurt and humiliate a woman, but will also contribute to the widespread misconception that Islam is a primitive and violent religion. In addition, Malaysia's reputation will plunge to the levels of Saudi Arabia, Yemen and the like. I hope common sense and piety prevail.

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, July 23rd, 2009.
I hope you are not a Muslim by calling this punishment as barbaric... Allah's words are for all Muslims then, now, the future and forever... If you are a Muslim then you should immediately Istighfar and ask for forgiveness from Allah SWT...

Submitted by Jack-O-Lantern on Thursday, July 23rd, 2009.
Maybe we should have violent crimes (armed robberies, homicides, kidnappings, etc) come under Islamic law too. On second thoughts, they have many Mat Rempits in Kelantan too!

Submitted by Anonymous on Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009.
5000 fine and whip 6 times for consuming beer in public. Hmmm...... Wonder how Syariah will sentence for stealing millions and millions of dollars, for lying again and again, and for causing death to innocent lives. Was she guilty of drinking in public? Hell yes. The law clearly states so. But why the selective persecution and prosecution? Hmm....

Submitted by Sam on Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009.
let the person who have not sin throw the first stone..

Submitted by Anonymous on Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009.
This is outrageous and not supposed to happened in a developed country like Malaysia. We are not the Talibans, please. I think the Syariah Law is getting out of hand. The judge must had read too much about the Syariah Law from other countries. Wake up, man!!!

Submitted by Con.com on Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009.
Syndicate content

Disclaimer | Contact Us | Back to Top Δ

Contact our advertising team to place an advertisement in Malay Mail, Malay Mail Online, and Mail on Sunday.

Copyright 2009 Malay Mail Sdn. Bhd.